Request #48564

Account Type:
Free Account
Dreamwidth:
Account Name: [personal profile] fae_of_the_rose
Style: (S2) core: public, layout: public, theme: public, user: custom
Email confirmed? Yes
cluster: 10
data version: 10
scheme: tropo-red
Media storage used: 0.212 MB (0.0%)
Support category:
Time posted:
Sat, 17 Feb 2024 20:35:11 GMT (82 weeks ago)
Status:
answered (still needs help)
Summary:
Bug When Approving Membership Request
Original Request:
So one of the communities I moderate (it's an RP comm) occasionally gets new journals asking to join one of the comms! And today (Feb 17 2024) me and two of the other mods ran into a weird bug where if we clicked "approve membership" in the request email, it would *reject* the request and tell us that the request had been handled. When we clicked "manage requests" in the email, it would *approve* the request and tell us that there were no requests waiting. We looked at the URLs of the links sent, and they say "approve", "reject", and "queue/members" in the URL, but for whatever reason they are not doing what they said they're supposed to be doing. We think it's been happening since at least last night, possibly longer.
Diagnostics: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:122.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/122.0
highlander_ii: Josh Duhamel sitting in a wooden box ([Josh D] inna box, _support) [personal profile] highlander_ii - Highlander II
Answer (#129645)
Posted: Sun, 17 Mar 2024 07:24:50 GMT (78 weeks ago)
Hi there -

Are you still experiencing this issue with community membership approvals? And is it only for this one community or have you experienced it with others as well?

Grazie,
H2
fae_of_the_rose: (Default) [personal profile] fae_of_the_rose - Fae Nunya
Comment (#129685)
Posted: Tue, 19 Mar 2024 16:42:34 GMT (78 weeks ago)
We are still experiencing the bug, but I haven't tried it with any other comms recently.
jennifer: painting of a girl with flowing red hair looking out to sea (miranda) [personal profile] jennifer - Jennifer
Answer (#132639)
Posted: Fri, 17 Jan 2025 16:05:15 GMT (34 weeks ago)
Hi there!

Just checking in on this again - are you still experiencing this issue?

Best,
--Jen
fae_of_the_rose: (Default) [personal profile] fae_of_the_rose - Fae Nunya
Comment (#132650)
Posted: Fri, 17 Jan 2025 21:45:52 GMT (34 weeks ago)
It seems to finally be fixed!
fae_of_the_rose: (Default) [personal profile] fae_of_the_rose - Fae Nunya
Comment (#132651)
Posted: Fri, 17 Jan 2025 21:46:00 GMT (34 weeks ago)
It seems to finally be fixed!
fae_of_the_rose: (Default) [personal profile] fae_of_the_rose - Fae Nunya
Comment (#132696)
Posted: Mon, 20 Jan 2025 03:32:39 GMT (34 weeks ago)
so we thought it was fixed but we found out today that it is not actually fixed and at least one of the comms I help run is still not working properly. so sorry to reopen this!
karzilla: a green fist above the word SMASH! (smash) [staff profile] karzilla - Karzilla, Destroyer of Bugs
Answer (#132841)
Posted: Thu, 30 Jan 2025 18:36:15 GMT (33 weeks ago)
Hello!

I've taken a look at the code that generates the emails and everything seems to be in order. The next time you receive the moderation approval message that doesn't work, can you copy and paste the text of the email (or source code of the email, if it's in HTML format) into this support request? Thanks!
fae_of_the_rose: (Default) [personal profile] fae_of_the_rose - Fae Nunya
Comment (#132912)
Posted: Sat, 08 Feb 2025 19:58:02 GMT (31 weeks ago)
below is the text of the email. this happened last night. for some context: it's an RP community that I'm a mod of, and the official mod email forwards notifications to our personal inboxes.

Hi [personal profile] kaisoumods,

[personal profile] orchidingold has requested to join your community [community profile] kaisouooc.

You can:

        Approve [personal profile] orchidingold's request to join
        Reject [personal profile] orchidingold's request to join
        Manage [community profile] kaisouooc's membership requests
        Manage your communities


--
Dreamwidth Team
Dreamwidth Studios


If you'd rather not get these updates, you can change your preferences at https://www.dreamwidth.org/manage/settings/?cat=notifications
jennifer: painting of a girl with flowing red hair looking out to sea (miranda) [personal profile] jennifer - Jennifer
Answer (#132926)
Posted: Sun, 09 Feb 2025 07:15:02 GMT (31 weeks ago)
Hi again!

Can you also include the links from the email alongside each action item?

Best,
--Jen
fae_of_the_rose: (Default) [personal profile] fae_of_the_rose - Fae Nunya
Comment (#132988)
Posted: Tue, 11 Feb 2025 15:59:49 GMT (31 weeks ago)
Hi kaisoumods,


orchidingold has requested to join your community kaisouooc.



You can:

    - Approve orchidingold's request to join:
        https://www.dreamwidth.org/approve/2579850.gbasqxxwdm8yhvw
    - Reject orchidingold's request to join:
        https://www.dreamwidth.org/reject/2579850.gbasqxxwdm8yhvw
    - Manage kaisouooc's membership requests:
        https://www.dreamwidth.org/communities/kaisouooc/queue/members
    - Manage your communities:
        https://www.dreamwidth.org/communities/list
--
Dreamwidth Team
Dreamwidth Studios

Here we go!
jennifer: painting of a girl with flowing red hair looking out to sea (miranda) [personal profile] jennifer - Jennifer
Answer (#133000)
Posted: Tue, 11 Feb 2025 22:35:33 GMT (31 weeks ago)
Hi again!

Thanks for sharing that! So this is what I'm seeing:

- The "Approve" link goes to https://www.dreamwidth.org/approve
- The "Reject" link goes to https://www.dreamwidth.org/reject
- The "Manage" link goes to /communities/kaisouooc/queue/members

Are you still saying that clicking each of those links does the wrong thing?

Best,
--Jen
fae_of_the_rose: (Default) [personal profile] fae_of_the_rose - Fae Nunya
Comment (#133004)
Posted: Tue, 11 Feb 2025 22:41:08 GMT (31 weeks ago)
I'm saying that when anyone attempts to join, they are automatically rejected. We don't have to click anything, they just get auto rejected.
You must log in to answer Support requests.
Go to: previous open request, next open request
Return to the list of open requests.
Back to the Support Area.